This editorial by Tom
Pauken discusses the new standardized test that Texas students must take, the
STAAR. This test has replaced the TAKS
test and the grade on this test accounts for fifteen percent of a student’s
final grade in that particular subject.
I am so glad I got out of high school when I did. These students may have to take up to fifteen
of these tests before they get out of high school. This test is supposed to make students
college ready, but what this test fails to take into account is that not all
students want to go to a four-year college after they graduate. Pauken does
recognize that there needs to be some way to check school accountability, but
he points out that even the commissioner
of the Texas Education Agency, Robert Scott, said that the system we have
implemented to do this “has become a perversion of its original intent.”
Pauken also points out that there are many necessary jobs out
there that do not require one to have a college degree. The emphasis on college may turn off some
students and as a result many drop out.
Pauken says, “Many of these
students, who may not thrive in a classroom setting, would benefit from the
opportunity to receive training that leads to an industry-certified
credential.” I believe this statement to
be true because I had a few friends in high school who were not the best
students and became very discouraged when they saw their TAKS scores. Yet, they were great with cars and if there were
a program at school that would train them to be an automotive technician then
they would have had a brighter future. The regimented schooling gave them this
mindset that if they didn’t succeed in school, they wouldn’t succeed in
anything.
There actually was a program in the school district in Houston that I went
to before I moved to Austin called the Miller Career Center. This was a place where students who didn’t
see themselves going to a university after high school could go and learn trades
such as automotive technician, cosmetology, EMT, and many others. Pauken also talks about the need for younger
people to become a part of the skilled trade workforce. Many welders, plumbers, and masonry craftsmen
are hitting retirement age, leaving a space that could be filled by these
students who do not plan on going to a university. I absolutely agree with
Pauken’s idea that schooling should be focused more on individual needs and we
should not measure each child’s intelligence based on a test.
I think Pauken’s audiences for this article are all the individuals involved
in education. Such as legislators,
teachers, parents, and students.
I believe that Pauken’s complaints, coupled with the complaints of many
others, about the current way of testing could possibly lead to changes in
legislation about standardized testing in Texas.
I believe Pauken is a knowledgeable man in many political areas since he
has held some political positions over the years. Though he never held any positions related
directly to education, but I still believe he is credible because I have seen
this phenomenon where students become discouraged because of the standardized
tests and may end up dropping out. Like
I said earlier, there should be programs in school that teach students trades
so those students who don’t feel like they’re cut out for college.